Thanks for the download. I think the citation numbers for birth and death on this person might be off. Should they be items 13 and 14? For the birth we have a secondary source (Genealogy of David Putman and his descendants, 1645-1916, pub'd 1916, pg 24) which I am guessing offers no primary source or that would be cited. I didn't spend a lot of time searching for that work but I would track it down as on its own it doesn't meet pre-1700 guides unless it cites a primary source. This may be a good clue but you still need either a primary source or significant circumstantial or secondary evidence (wills, etc) from the period.